Question #1
The ending of the film was more dark and mysterious more
consistent with film noir where the bad guy "Walter Neff" is shortcoming in getting happy
ending whereas the novel ending was more predictable where the bad guys get away. Phyllis's and
Walter's world was closing in on them and their separation first presents itself in the scene where
she overhears Walter talking to keys. Walter tells Phyllis they should wait awhile before they see
each other again and she takes it as Walter pretty much giving up on her. Walter ends up going to
Phyllis's house with murder in mind the suspense builds up as he closes her
blinds diming the scenery were wondering what's going to happen, who's going to
make the first move as we know Phyllis is packing also with same intentions as
Walter on her mind. Phyllis fires the first shot right into Walters chest, then
their is a sense of a bit of confusion as Walters slowly walk towards her and
she's slowly dropping her gun only to hug him and . Just when Phyllis shows
some type of humanity Walter shoots and kills her consistent with film noir" erotic, weird and cruel. In the end Walter is defeated mainly by
Phyllis's gunshot to his chest and only to have his fate/freedom in the hands
of keys who he feared throughout the film, in the film he ends of with smoking
a cigarette lighten by keys which is kind of like a gangster and more
consistent with film noir as opposed to the novel where its a bit confusing and
there's no big showdown or blood bath only a confusing boat cruse with a
possibility of suicide...
Question #9
Your right on how Walter and Keyes sort of had each other’s backs and how even though Keyes looked hard on the outside, he was soft on the inside and cared for Walter. Between the both of them as we said in the class they had kind of a bro-mance with each other. Also about the ending of the novel compared to the ending of the film. Your right the film is really more based on how the genre should be. The fact that at end of the novel, Walter and Phyllis get away doesn’t go with what noir is. Overall good job keep it up.
ReplyDelete" finally lighting Walters cigarette and Walter in what most would call expressing the last words of a dying man to his significant other "I love you to" sounds like a love triangle straight from court TV wicked...." I like how you phrased that it actually does feel like it was a love triangle, the film makes this more obvious to the eye as you see the movie you can see the special bond in between them not just like that of a employer and an employee but more of a relation between two friends that always been there for each other. I liked your writing.
ReplyDelete